In which scenario would a pragmatist likely choose their methodology?

A pragmatist often prioritizes the research question and the context of the study over strict adherence to a particular method. In this case, the scenario in which both phenomenological and social constructivist approaches are applicable aligns with a pragmatist's worldview. This perspective recognizes that different methodologies can provide valuable insights and that combining techniques can enhance understanding of complex phenomena. By selecting strategies based on their usefulness to address specific research needs, pragmatists demonstrate flexibility and a focus on practical outcomes rather than theoretical allegiance.

In this context, the mention of both phenomenological and social constructivist approaches indicates an openness to multiple perspectives and methods, which is characteristic of pragmatism. This contrasts sharply with scenarios that suggest a rigid adherence to a single method or a clear preference based solely on subjective experiences or quantitative data, which would limit the researcher's ability to adapt their approach based on the situation and the multifaceted nature of the issue at hand.